Two-Thirds of Second-Hand Memory Cards Contain Data From Previous Owners

Two-Thirds of Second-Hand Memory Cards Contain Data From Previous Owners

Written by / Courtesy of Bleeping Computer

A recent study conducted by academics from the University of Hertfordshire in the UK has revealed that almost two-thirds of second-hand memory cards still contain remnants of personal data from previous owners.

For their study, researchers analyzed 100 second-hand SD and micro SD memory cards purchased from eBay, conventional auctions, second-hand shops, and other sources over a four-month period.

Researchers recovered selfies, intimate photos, personal docs

All in all, researchers say the memory cards they recovered were previously used in smartphones and tablets, but some cards were also used cameras, SatNav systems, and even drones.

The research team says the analysis process consisted of creating a bit-by-bit image of the card and then using freely available software to see if they could recover any data from the card.

Their efforts were successful and worrisome at the same time, as the team says it managed to recover data from the memory cards, including intimate photos, selfies, passport copies, contact lists, navigation files, pornography, resumes, browsing history, identification numbers, and other personal documents.

People don’t wipe their devices properly

“Often the problem is not that people don’t wipe their SD cards; it’s that they don’t do it properly,” said Paul Bischoff, Privacy Advocate for, the company who commissioned the study.

“Simply deleting a file from a device only removes the reference that points to where a computer could find that file in the card memory. It doesn’t actually delete the ones and zeros that make up the file,” Bischoff said.

“That data remains on the card until it is overwritten by something else,” he also added. “For this reason, it’s not enough to just highlight all the files in a memory card and hit the delete key. Retired cards need to be fully erased and reformatted.”

Special software exists, including open-source one, that can help users properly wipe their devices by deleting files, and then overwriting it with random data so the previous information is permanently and irrevocably removed from a device a user wants to sell.

This procedure is not recommended for memory cards alone, but for all media storage devices, such as regular hard drives or USB sticks.

Past research

The problem detailed in the University of Hertfordshire study is not unique. A study conducted in 2010 revealed that 50% of the second-hand mobile phones sold on eBay contained data from previous owners.

A 2012 report from the UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO)  revealed that one in ten second-hand hard drives still contained data from previous owners. A similar study from 2015 found that three-quarters of used hard drives contained data from previous owners.

The full breakdown of the University of Hertfordshire study data is available below:

? 36 were not wiped at all, neither the original owner nor the seller took any steps to remove the data.
? 29 appeared to have been formatted, but data could still be recovered “with minimal effort.”
? 2 cards had their data deleted, but it was easily recoverable
? 25 appeared to have been properly wiped using a data erasing tool that overwrites the storage area, so nothing could be recovered.
? 4 could not be accessed (read: were broken).
? 4 had no data present, but the reason could not be determined

Read the original article over at Bleeping Computer.